GST – To Be or Not To Be


This monsoon session of parliament will go on from July 18th 2016 to August 20th 2016, during which we hope to see the biggest tax reform in a decade – the GST to pass. Already dominating the headlines, the GST has been hailed as is one of the most awaited reforms that could help streamline the taxes that we pay on goods and services.

Before discussing the GST Bill, let’s take a quick look on what GST is all about and the impact it can have on your investments.

The all-encompassing Goods and Services Tax (GST)

In very broad terms, we in India pay taxes to the Government in two forms – Direct and Indirect. Direct taxes are simple; they are collected directly from those who are liable to pay it. The common examples are Income tax, Property tax, and Gift tax.

On the other hand, in indirect taxes the money is collected and paid by somebody other than the person liable to pay them. Some of the important indirect taxes are Customs Duty, Excise Duty, Sales Tax, VAT, Service Tax, and STT. Currently, the indirect tax system in India is quite complicated. The Central and State Governments levy taxes separately, resulting in overlaps.

The newly conceived framework of the GST will replace these indirect taxes. GST will have a ‘dual’ structure, which means it will have two main components- Central GST and State GST. There will also be a third component called integrated GST to tackle inter-state transactions.

Experts expect that GST will lead to a unified tax market, improvement in tax collection and a broadened tax base. Firstly it will help in easy transportation of goods. Currently, each state has checkpoint for entry of goods. It is as if every state is a different country, GST will smoothen the flow. It will reduce the logistics cost for companies. Secondly, the tax rates can be lower for some products as there is a lower single tax structure under GST. Currently, there is a 2-tier structure with both States and Centre levying tax. For example, the automobile industry is talked as a beneficiary of GST as the proposed tax is lower.

Thirdly, GST will benefit by widening the tax base. Many who are excluded currently will pay tax based on value addition. It will bring a climate of improved tax compliance.

Getting GST rolling

This time around the Government is hopeful of introducing GST before 2016 ends, hence the grand push during the monsoon session of parliament. When the GST law is enacted it will require the creation of the GST Network, an IT backbone of GST, which will facilitate online registration, tax payment and return filing. But before that the Bill needs to be passed in both houses of the Parliament. Thereafter it needs to be ratified by a minimum of 15 States in their respective assemblies before the President can give his assent for its enactment.

However unlike other tax changes, the introduction of GST is far more complicated. It requires re-writing certain parts of the Indian Constitution.

Clearing roadblocks for GST

So why does introduction of GST require a Constitutional Amendment?

You see, the Constitution lays out the distribution of power to tax between the Centre and States. While the Centre is empowered to tax services and goods up to the production stage, only the States have the power to tax sale of goods. Moreover, the States are not empowered to impose tax on imports. Therefore, it is essential to have Constitutional Amendments for empowering both the Central and State Governments to levy tax on the ‘supply of goods and services’ and tax on imports, other important issues.

Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Parliament, passed the Constitutional Amendment Bill in May 2015. So now the ball is in the upper house, the Rajya Sabha, which will witness the passing the constitutional amendment.

GST and the stock markets

If things work out in this monsoon session of the Parliament and GST begins to roll, it would certainly be something the markets would cheer.

However for companies to actually start benefitting from it will take considerable time, in a complex economy like India. That said making GST happen will send the important message out to the world that policy makers in India are serious about economic reforms. To that end GST certainly is a step in the right direction, and is to be lauded.

Disclaimer, Statutory Details & Risk Factors:

Please read full article  @ source:

2 Replies to “GST – To Be or Not To Be”

  1. Varun says:

    I believe the GST implementation is / will be a failure of epic proportions.

    All the Government has done is make taxation:
    i) More complicated & convoluted
    ii) Potential source of confusion for importers/exporters and other business

    Every single country that implements a VAT / GST system, has a singular rate across the country.

    How different is the ‘dual-GST model’ from the existing CST/VAT model?

    Essentially, it’s just a re-labelling of the current model.

    There should be a SINGULAR GST rate across the country, regardless of inter-state or intra-state transactions.
    They really need to get their thumbs out of their **** and properly re-think this.

    The ultimate goal should be to break down existing trade barriers, not put up new ones.

    1. Admin says:

      Dear visitor,
      Thanks for your view and request you use better language.
      Although the complications are still being defined , it is early for fore-judge the entire tax structure.
      In future, Dual GST can be converged into single GST. Since you are aware of the Indian constitutional structure, it will take some time for the government to streamline the indirect tax law. One of the benefit of GST should be removal of double taxation that exists when excise is considered as cost to its distribution channel.
      Thanks once again !!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Solve this and then Post Comment *

scroll to top